Guideline 15
Publication medium
Authors select the publication medium carefully, with due regard for its quality and visibility in the relevant field of discourse. Researchers who assume the role of editor carefully select where they will carry out this activity. The scientific/academic quality of a contribution does not depend on the medium in which it is published.
Explanation
In addition to publication in books and journals, authors may also consider academic repositories, data and software repositories, and blogs. A new or unknown publication medium is evaluated to assess its seriousness.
A key criterion to selecting a publication medium is whether it has established guidelines on good research practice.
Comments
- Publication of scientific results in preprints
-
Minimum standards of quality assurance for research publications
Several checking procedures and quality assurance measures must be ensured by the publishers or the persons responsible at the publication venue.
-
Predatory journals and hijacked journals
Predatory journals are dubious publication media that only appear to uphold academic standards. Hijacked journals deliberately imitate the appearance of reputable journals in order to deceive authors.
-
Publication organs in open access
Open access publications ensure permanent and free access to research results for readers.
-
Quality standards in connection with rapid publication
Rapid publication of research data and findings by no means allows any compromise to be made in terms of accepted quality standards in the given field.
-
Repositories
Repositories are locations to store digital content.
-
Selection of reputable publication venues
When choosing a suitable publication venue, it is helpful to bear certain questions in mind.
-
Further links to publication media
-
Archiving data in the earth sciences and environmental sciences
Best practice example – PANGAEA
-
Diverse (digital) publication options in the humanities and social sciences
In the humanities and social sciences, a variety of formats in different media are suitable for publishing research results in the humanities, which should be carefully assessed prior to publication. Important criteria here include the reputability of the institution as well as its conditions of access and long-term archiving.
-
Publication media in engineering sciences
In the engineering sciences, publications appear in a broad and diverse range of publication media. In addition to the academic journals, international conference proceedings and patents are relevant.
-
Publication media in the life sciences
Preprints are academic publications that are published without peer review, thereby allowing for the rapid dissemination of research results.